The Deployment-Transformation Gap in Rural Municipal Digital Government: An Exploratory Study of Fragmented Institutionalization
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Digital transformation (DT) in government produces uneven organizational outcomes: municipalities may operate sophisticated digital infrastructures while citizen-facing public services remain weakly integrated. This exploratory qualitative study asks how actors involved in municipal DT in rural Germany perceive its organizational institutionalization and which interpretive patterns structure their assessments. It draws on six focus group discussions with 30 actors involved in municipal DT across 25 municipalities in South Westphalia, Germany, and an embedded single-item rating exercise used solely as an elicitation device. Participants described DT as neither marginal nor fully taken for granted. Institutionalization fragmented across normalization, legitimacy, ownership, and coupling and was mediated by scriptedness, boundary compliance signaling, and standardization. Three interpretive patterns structured these assessments: Compliance-Driven Symbolic Adoption, Silo-Contained Routinization, and Authorized Experimentation. Conceptually, the article develops fragmented institutionalization as a configurational explanation of the deployment–transformation gap, showing why technical implementation can advance without corresponding organizational embedding. Practically, it identifies dimension-specific intervention points for municipal leaders and policymakers. Because the study is qualitative, cross-sectional, and geographically bounded, it develops an analytical explanation rather than estimating the prevalence of these configurations or their effects on service performance.
DOI: 10.1145/3849877
Author: Marcel Patalon
Institution: South Westphalia University of Applied Sciences
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Funder: Fachhochschule Südwestfalen
OpenAlex ID: W7236705024
