Work

Operational Sufficiency of Object Individuation: Exact Criteria, Conflict Diagnostics, and Access Protocols

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Scientific descriptions retain some distinctions between states while identifying others. This paper asks when such an identification preserves enough information for a specified outcome-recording procedure. In a finite framework, object individuation is represented by a map qc:Y→Zc. Exact deterministic sufficiency requires the outcome map to factor through qc; probabilistic sufficiency requires the outcome law to be constant on each fibre of qc. Insufficiency is localized by conflicting state pairs and a conflict graph. Refinement through an admissible feature library is characterized by the requirement that every conflicting pair be separated. Approximate sufficiency is studied under total variation loss, with uniform and ensemble-average errors treated separately. The binary case admits an explicit minimax solution, whereas pairwise proximity alone does not characterize approximate sufficiency for general finite outcome spaces. To distinguish informative descriptions from accessible information, an access protocol is specified by a joint kernel for the observed record and the resulting state, together with a resource cost. This formulation separates reconstruction of the pre-protocol outcome law from reconstruction of the law associated with the realized post-protocol state. A recording-relative disturbance measure bounds the difference between the corresponding worst-case expected risks. A complete four-state example connects individuation, conflict diagnosis, refinement, noisy access, and decoding. For the specified binary-noise protocol, the optimal worst-case expected total variation error is 0.1δ, where 0≤δ≤1/2 is the bit-flip probability. By contrast, the optimal error guarantee over every possible record remains 0.05 whenever 0<δ≤1/2. The results concern finite mathematical models. They do not establish physical realizability of the example protocol, a universal measurement theory, or a derivation of quantum probabilities.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236709629
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10