Work

Feedback, Delay and Discontinuity in Market Crashes

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A price decline can induce a constrained holder to sell. We study how quickly this feedback reaches the clearing price when price, inventory and a desk’s risk forecast adjust on different time scales. With known response slopes and a controlled external shock, one observation of the forecast-to-price response at a nonzero frequency, together with the initial slope and signed area of the price step response, identifies all three adjustment times except on an explicit cancellation surface. On that surface an entire family of forecast clocks produces identical observations. Switching off a nonzero immediate forecast response resolves this ambiguity and implies a testable restriction across frequencies. We give deterministic bounds for finite records. At fixed forecast speed, stronger sensitivity to price changes can destabilize the interior equilibrium. For one explicit parameter set we prove that inventory saturation supports an attracting periodic orbit of 49.23 minutes. In a concentrated-holder example, declining marginal depth produces a $2.36 discontinuity in the quasistatic clearing price of a $100 stock. Price and broker records for Meta and ViacomCBS establish when losses appeared. A causal decomposition would require signed executions and a counterfactual for the price without those sales.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236713308
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10