Translates of completely normal elements and the Morgan–Mullen conjecture: unproved cases, corrected thresholds, and complete restoration
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Paper, verification programs and data for an audit of T. Garefalakis and G. Kapetanakis, "Translates of completely normal elements and the Morgan–Mullen conjecture", Canad. Math. Bull., published online 28 May 2026 (doi:10.4153/S0008439526102082, arXiv:2509.23245). That paper proves the existence of primitive completely normal elements in (n1, n2)-partially completely basic extensions F_{q^n}/F_q for n1 = 2, 3 (Theorem 7.2(1)). Two families with q = 2 claimed by the theorem are not covered by its proof: 1. q = 2, n1 = 2. The computation discards every n2 by a parity argument that confuses p | n2 with p | n; 63 extensions were never tested. They satisfy the paper's own test.2. q = 2, n1 = 3, n odd. The method of the paper gives nothing here, yet the theorem contains these infinitely many extensions. We show that ab + a + a^2 is completely normal when a and b are completely normal in F_{2^n1} and F_{2^n2} and gcd(n2, ord_{n1}(2)) = 1, which gives the same sufficient condition as for n even. Both families are proved, so Theorem 7.2(1) holds as stated. The note also recomputes Table 1 of the paper and explains its discrepant entries, gives effective thresholds for the asymptotic Theorem 6.4, completes the unfinished computation for n1 = 4, n2 ≥ 256, and corrects Remark 5.1. Contents: the note (LaTeX source and PDF), the verification program (Python 3; sympy, numpy, mpmath), the script producing the figure, and the output data (JSON files and a text log). A full run takes about five minutes and regenerates all data. See README.md for the correspondence between program sections, statements of the note and data files. Source repository: https://github.com/Ruqing1963/kapetanakis-translates-cmb-audit
Author: Chen, Ruqing
Language: English
Subfield: Discrete Mathematics and Combinatorics
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: finite fields, field extensions, parity argument
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236729848
