Work

Limited Intrinsic CO2/CH4 Selectivity in Imine-Linked COF-LZU-1: Evidence from PBE-D3 Adsorption Energetics and Binary-Mixture Monte Carlo Simulations

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Imine-linked covalent organic frameworks (COFs) are widely proposed for CO2/CH4 separation, yet the intrinsic selectivity of the archetypal framework COF-LZU1 has not been quantified against a transparent baseline. Here, periodic PBE-D3 calculations and grand canonical Monte Carlo (GCMC) simulations are combined to test whether pristine COF-LZU1 discriminates between CO2 and CH4. At three positions spanning the 1.8 nm channel, relaxed PBE-D3 adsorption energies are −3.10, −3.66, and −8.90 kJ mol-1 for CO2 and −3.13, −3.63, and −8.76 kJ mol-1 for CH4; CO2 binds more strongly than CH4 by at most 0.14 kJ mol-1, at the confined site near the imine linkage. Consistently, GCMC simulations of equimolar mixtures (TraPPE, DREIDING, DDEC6 charges, Ewald electrostatics, 14 Å cutoff with analytic tail corrections) give low selectivities of 1.15–1.71 between 273 and 323 K and 0.1–10 bar, and 1.20–1.38 at 298 K, rising with pressure and falling with temperature. At 223 K and 7–10 bar, CO2 fills about 80% of the pore volume and the selectivity reaches about 11, a pore-filling effect and not intrinsic discrimination. Replacing EPM2 CO2, a 12 Å cutoff, and no tail corrections by the final force-field set raises the selectivity by 7–27%, so selectivities near unity are force-field sensitive. The weak simulated selectivity, together with the near-equal DFT binding energies, defines a baseline that functionalization, for example with Ag+, must overcome.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236739505
Cites: 22
Cited by:
Related to: 10