Work

A Reasons-based Theory of Argument Schemes in Practical Argumentation

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Existing theories of argument schemes in practical argumentation fail to provide a satisfactory solution to the following problem: how to adequately reconstruct an argument representing reasons that provide convergent support for a standpoint by means of an argument scheme? In the present paper, I propose a theory of argument schemes in practical argumentation that does provide a satisfactory solution to this problem. As far as this theory defines the validity of practical arguments in terms of the weighing of reasons, we can say that it is a reasons-based theory. The utility of the proposed theory is demonstrated in two ways – by demonstrating its compatibility with a general account of how real-life practical argumentation can be explained on the basis of empirical data regarding cultural value priorities, and through the analysis and explanation of a case study – the 2018 Bulgarian government debate about the ratification of the Istanbul convention.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236739717
Cites: 32
Cited by:
Related to: 10