Work

A Judicial Quest for Solid Legal Ground. The Role of Perceived Societal Impact in Judicial Decision-Making in PIL Cases

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Public Interest Litigation (PIL) cases inherently extend beyond the interests of the litigating parties and affect society at large. Hence, such rulings may provoke political and societal backlash. In the Netherlands, recent high-impact judicial decisions have sparked public debate, incomprehension and criticism. Courts are accused of encroaching upon the political domain, the government appears increasingly reluctant to comply with judicial orders, and legislative initiatives have been proposed to restrict the access of public interest organisations to the courts. In short, the legitimacy of judicial interventions in PIL cases is challenged. This contribution examines how courts address the potential societal impact of PIL cases in their decision-making, and in doing so, construct legitimacy at the intersection of law, society and politics against a background of increasing backlash against the exercise of judicial authority. Drawing on a mixed-methods approach it demonstrates that while a ruling’s anticipated impact is no independent consideration in determining the outcome of case, it serves as a factor shaping how courts understand and articulate their institutional role.
Institution: Utrecht University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,550
OpenAlex ID: W7236740298
FWCI:
Cites: 5
Cited by:
Related to: 10