Systemic Barriers to Implementing the Essential Package of Health Services in a Pilot District in Pakistan: A Qualitative Study of Decision-Makers, Managers and Frontline Providers
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background/Objectives: Essential packages of health services (EPHS) are designed to translate universal health coverage commitments into a defined set of services, yet more often fail in delivery than in design. Pakistan began developing a national EPHS in 2018; Tando Allah Yar district in Sindh became the pilot site, with implementation beginning in August 2024. This study explored barriers to implementation in the pilot district as perceived by decision-makers, managers and healthcare providers. Methods: Exploratory qualitative study of 18 in-depth interviews with purposively selected participants holding direct EPHS responsibility: decision-makers, managers and healthcare providers (n = 6 each). Interviews were held face-to-face in English or Urdu between January and March 2025. Data were analysed in NVivo 12 Plus using framework analysis structured by the WHO health system building blocks, with inductive coding for issues outside it. Results: Participants reported barriers in all six building blocks, framed differently by group: decision-makers identified systemic causes, managers operational consequences, and providers effects on patients. Five predominated: centralised financial control and rigid line-item budgets; weak coordination between federal, provincial and district tiers, compounded by political interference; shortages of Lady Health Workers and specialists; slow procurement and unreliable supply chains; and paper-based reporting. Three cross-cutting themes were derived inductively: perceived erosion of community trust, geographic and resource inequity, and staff demotivation from heavy workloads and dual roles. Conclusions: In the early pilot phase, the barriers participants reported lay mainly in the delivery system rather than in the package itself and were interdependent rather than isolated. They should be addressed together and assessed in other districts as province-wide scale-up proceeds.
Source: Healthcare
Institution: Aga Khan University
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,258
OpenAlex ID: W7236750360
