Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Studies of animal color patterns have provided important insights into evolution, particularly the genetic and developmental bases of adaptation, natural selection’s role in molding both nuptial and nonbreeding traits, and sexual/social selection’s role in ornament evolution. Here we review these topics for the threespine stickleback, a leading evolutionary model. Concerning genetics, we find that melanic characters are the best elucidated, with one to multiple genes indicated. Red coloration appears polygenic and candidate genes include ttc39b, but manipulations using CRISPR-Cas9 are needed. When red is present in females as well as males, shared QTL are involved, but red-correlated gene expression can also be sex-specific. Plasticity is important for both conspicuous and cryptic color patches, with light environment critical. Regarding selection, lateral barring appears adaptive against predation, but opportunities for experimental evolution studies need to be pursued—also for nuptial color. For males, red intensity is often correlated with condition, aggression and dominance, as well as successful offspring rearing, but contrary results have also been obtained. Further, there is no direct evidence that benefits resulting from choice of mate drive preference evolution. Sensory drive, however, is increasingly supported. Genetic correlations, for example between the expression and perception of color, may be important yet their underpinnings are largely unknown. Comparative data from related species bolster observations of threespine stickleback social behavior which suggest, first, that spine color merits additional research attention; and second, that a comparative approach based in current sensory ecology methods and considering multiple color patches is likely to provide valuable insights.
Institutions: East Carolina University, Davidson College
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: Gasterosteus aculeatus, color pattern evolution, nuptial coloration, red coloration, polygenic inheritance, candidate genes, quantitative trait loci, phenotypic plasticity, light environment, predation, sexual selection, sensory drive, mate choice, color perception, color expression, social behavior
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,690
Funder: East Carolina University
OpenAlex ID: W7236754364
