Ecotourism Governance in West Lampung: A Normative Legal Analysis of Harmonizing Customary Law and Environmental Sustainability
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The expansion of ecotourism in West Lampung, a region known for its plantation ecosystems and coffee-centered agro-tourism, has raised regulatory tensions, understood here as conflicting, overlapping, or uncoordinated norms, between statutory environmental protections and Adat (customary) governance institutions. This article examines the legal alignment between state environmental policy and customary law and assesses whether collaborative governance arrangements could address enforcement deficits. Using a normative legal methodology (statute and conceptual approaches) in which legal pluralism, polycentric governance, and collaborative governance each serve a distinct analytical function (diagnosing recognition, testing institutional structure, and assessing process design), it analyzes national statutes and implementing regulations, provincial and district regulations on tourism planning and customary institutions, and documented Saibatin customary practices. The analysis identifies three types of tension in the legal texts reviewed: conditional recognition of customary authority under Article 18B paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution and sectoral forestry rules; overlapping competences among tourism, environmental, forestry, spatial-planning, and village authorities; and the absence of a mechanism for involving Adat institutions in environmental approval and monitoring. The article argues that embedding customary principles within formal administrative arrangements may support biodiversity preservation, provided that each institution rests on an identifiable legal basis. Its contribution is to operationalize legal authority as an explicit analytical dimension of polycentric collaborative governance through a norm-by-norm authority test; the proposed three-tier model is a separate policy proposal. The findings are normative-analytical and have not been empirically tested.
Source: Jurnal Ilmiah Kutei
Institutions: Institut Pariwisata Trisakti, Kyungsung University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Funder: Kyungsung University
OpenAlex ID: W7236758736
