From Recovery to Fixation: Attachment-Driven Secondary Gain in Persistent Somatic Symptoms Following Severe Illness—A Critical Review and Integrative Model
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A significant subset of patients continue to experience persistent, distressing somatic symptoms long after biomedical resolution of a severe acute illness, yet the developmental transition from acute illness to chronic somatic fixation remains under-theorised. This critical review proposes an integrative model in which post-illness somatic fixation represents a maladaptive attachment strategy. Drawing on attachment theory (Bowlby, 1969), secondary gain (Schoen, 1993; Fishbain et al., 1995), and mentalisation-based accounts of persistent somatic complaints (Luyten & Fonagy, 2017), we propose that for individuals with histories of insecure attachment, childhood adversity, or emotional invalidation, the intense care received during acute illness may unconsciously activate a dependency on the “sick role” as a means of securing unmet attachment needs. We synthesise evidence linking insecure and disorganised attachment to somatisation (Waldinger et al., 2006; Vesterling & Koglin, 2020; Greenman et al., 2024), propose a five-stage model of the transition from acute illness to fixation, identify key moderating and mediating factors, and outline attachment-informed clinical implications for assessment, prevention, and psychotherapeutic intervention. This model is offered as a hypothesis-generating synthesis rather than a validated theory; it does not propose a new biological mechanism, but integrates two largely separate literatures—attachment theory and secondary gain research in psychosomatic medicine—into a single developmental account, and we outline a concrete agenda of longitudinal, mechanistic, and intervention studies required to test it.
Author: Kumar, Ramesh
Language: English
Subfield: Psychiatry and Mental health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236761300
