A Universal Dependence Metric: Four Numbers That Replace Independence
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: When correlated components are modeled as independent, the probability of simultaneous failure is understated by a factor that grows exponentially in system size — 50,773× for five assets with heavy-tailed dependence, exceeding 10^89 at fifty. We define eight axioms a dependence measure must satisfy (independence baseline, comonotonicity ceiling, marginal invariance, tail sensitivity, monotonicity, dimensional scaling, decomposability, continuity), show that CDF-based divergences fail dimensional scaling and nonparametric mutual information estimation degrades beyond moderate dimension, and construct a four-number metric: D_G (Gaussian copula mutual information from pairwise ranks), D_T (tail excess ratio vs. Gaussian baseline), D_S (upper/lower tail persistence slope), and D_H (hidden dependence excess). We prove D_G is a lower bound on true mutual information, decomposes via Schur complements, and satisfies most axioms — with explicit counterexamples where it does not. The metric discriminates copula families with 100% power at n = 1,000, predicts out-of-sample tail losses (r = 0.82, in simulation), and catches adversarial evasion attacks via D_H at fire rates as low as 0.1%. These are properties of the metric on simulated data. On real market data the evidence is negative: in five pre-registered out-of-sample studies the capital charge did not detect stress better than a rolling average correlation and did not predict forward breaches of a portfolio's own value-at-risk beyond recent volatility; tested in isolation within strata of both correlation and volatility, D_T also failed. For the equicorrelated Gaussian copula, log R ≈ c(ρ) · D_G, confirming that independence mispricing is exponential in measured dependence. We derive a capital charge formula K from the four numbers and validate the metric across finance, engineering reliability, epidemiology, supply chains, and machine-learning ensembles — five domains where the independence assumption hides catastrophic compound risk.
Author: Zisckind, Tal
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236761341
