Mid-Crown Colour Change of the Aligner–Replica System with Straight Extended Versus Scalloped Clear Aligner Trimming Lines: A Prospective Non-Randomised Split-Mouth Clinical Trial
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Background/Objectives: The trimming line alters the fit and retention of clear aligners, but whether it affects colour change in their visible surface during intraoral wear is unknown. This study compared colour changes at mid-crown, the centre of the labial surface, between straight trimming lines extended over the gingiva and scalloped lines following the gingival margin. Methods: In this prospectively registered (NCT07628491) non-randomised split-mouth trial, designed as a superiority comparison, 50 patients in the finishing stage of clear aligner treatment wore both configurations, one per arch, allocated by a pre-specified rule. Coded appliances were measured extraorally with a spectrophotometer over composite replicas at three mid-crown sites per arch, at baseline and after 14 days of intraoral wear; colour at the margin was not assessed. The primary outcome was the arch-level CIEDE2000 colour difference (ΔE00) of the aligner–replica system. Results: All participants completed the study without adverse events. Mid-crown colour change did not differ detectably between the trimming lines: mean ΔE00 was 1.38 with straight extended and 1.34 with scalloped lines (paired difference, computed from unrounded values, 0.05; 95% confidence interval −0.21 to 0.31; p = 0.71), and the estimate remained close to zero in sensitivity analyses. Paired differences varied widely and in both directions (standard deviation 0.91; between-arch correlation 0.41). Conclusions: In compliant patients wearing one aligner material for 14 days with minimal exposure to staining, the trimming line did not detectably affect mid-crown colour change in the aligner–replica system, although equivalence cannot be claimed. The variance estimates can inform future split-mouth studies.
Source: Journal of Clinical Medicine
DOI: 10.3390/jcm15229068
Language: English
Subfield: Orthodontics
Field: Dentistry
Domain: Health Sciences
Keyword: clear aligners
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,137
Funder: European Commission
Award: G9001399324
OpenAlex ID: W7236767151
