Condemning in the Name of the City: Socrates, Jesus and Wrongdoing in the Name of the Good
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Author's translation. English translation, by the author, of the Portuguese original: DIETRICH, Pablo. Condenar em nome da cidade: Sócrates, Jesus e o mal praticado em nome do bem (unpublished manuscript, 2026). License CC BY 4.0. The trials of Socrates, in 399 BCE, and of Jesus, around 30 CE, are compared in order to ask to what extent they reveal a common structure in the way a person comes to be understood as a threat and in the way that understanding takes part in forming reasons to act against him. The analysis applies the cycle of influence, understanding and action, without assuming that it works as a mechanism, together with the criterion of participation, which separates identifying those affected by a decision from the obligation, normatively assumed, to justify the decision to them. Each claim is placed at one of four levels: textual report, external corroboration, historical reconstruction and philosophical interpretation. The sources support different parts of the cycle, with unequal strength: the Apology describes the prior formation of Socrates' image, while the passion narratives present shifts in the wording of the charge according to the authority it addresses. The best-supported convergence lies in the preventive justification of death attributed to Anytus by the Platonic defence and to Caiaphas by the Johannine narrative. An examination of the counter-penalty, of the speech of the Laws in the Crito and of Kelsen's reading of the trial of Jesus shows that being heard is not the same as receiving reasons, and that the competence of those who decide does not settle the justification owed to the condemned. Responsibility is distributed by position, against the collective attributions of guilt produced by later memory.
Author: Dietrich, Pablo
Institution: Estácio (Brazil)
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236779694
