Work

Challenges of Annual Performance Evaluation Report (APER) System to Employee Performance in Nigeria's Public Service System

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study investigated the challenges of annual performance evaluation report (APER) system to employee performance in Nigeria’s public service system. The specific objectives were to identify APER’s challenges, explore how it undermines suitable job placement, efficiency, proper promotion and retention, and staff competencies and behaviours. Anchored on Expectancy Theory, the study adopted the Ex Post Facto research design utilising qualitative method of data collection based on secondary sources and content analysis. Findings revealed a number of challenges of APER which include, lack of training and resources, subjectivity and lack of transparency, bureaucratic inefficiency, politicisation, unclear performance indicators, weak feedback mechanisms, lack of alignment between appraisals and career progression, its treatment as annual ritual replete with appraisal errors and reliability, validity and rating biases. Further revealed was that APER undermines suitable job placement given a high rate of subjective indices warranting placement of officers at unsuitable positions. More so, APER implementation undermines employees’ efficiency and poor service delivery preceded by poor scrutiny of staff performance and handling jobs with laxity and levity across agencies. Besides, APER undermines proper promotion and retention as there are no stipulated standards to qualify for good conduct, efficient performance and acceptable qualifications for promotion. Ultimately, manipulations of the APER system result in turnover and recycling of incompetent and poor quality public officers. The study recommends that the newly introduced Performance Management System to replace APER should be strictly implemented in accordance with set objectives to avoid the pitfalls of APER. Keywords: APER System, Employee Performance, Public Service, Efficiency, Competence.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236782075
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10