A Break-Even Threshold Framework for Circular Digital Transitions on Family Farms: Precision Agriculture and Blockchain Traceability in Rural Colombia
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Digital technologies are promoted as enablers of circular agri-food systems, yet family farms lack tools to judge whether such investments pay off, and economic data at this scale are often unreliable. This study develops a break-even threshold framework that evaluates digital investments using only physical and price variables, derives three propositions on entry costs, decision robustness and unreliable data, and applies it to precision agriculture with blockchain traceability on 100 family farms in Sumapaz, Bogotá, Colombia, 50 of them adopters. Three circular dimensions were assessed: the narrowing of resource flows, value retention and chain governance. Adopting farms used 26 to 42% fewer inputs per tonne of output and recorded fewer batch rejections and intermediaries. The investment broke even with a yield gain of 2.51% against an observed differential of 19.95%, and all farms remained viable if only half of that differential were retained, if half of the additional output went unsold or if technology costs doubled. Viability depended on the ratio of investment to farm area, with an elasticity of −0.65, and no price premium for verified origin was found. The framework turns transition narratives into a computable decision rule and identifies entry cost as the main barrier for smallholders.
Source: Preprints.org
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236785485
