Work

Electricity Intensity and Co₂e Emission Performance in Paper Production: Benchmarking and Decomposition Analysis of an Industrial Plant in Türkiye

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The pulp and paper industry is characterized by substantial energy and resource requirements, making improvements in process efficiency important for reducing environmental impacts. This study evaluates the electricity- and process-related performance of an anonymized paper-production facility in Türkiye through an integrated benchmarking and decomposition framework. Plant-level data were used to quantify electricity intensity, electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity, recycled-pulp utilization, steam utilization, and wastewater generation. The facility was evaluated against a product-matched European reference for recycled-fibre (RCF) mills without deinking producing packaging paper, an industrial reference from Türkiye, and broader sector-level estimates for Türkiye, Europe, and the United States. The analyzed plant exhibited an electricity intensity of 320 kWh/ton, approximately 8.6% below the lower boundary and 28.9% below the upper boundary of the product-matched European reference range of 350–450 kWh/ton. Its electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity was approximately 141 kg CO₂e/ton. When the product-matched European electricity-intensity range was combined with the European grid emission factor of 0.251 kg CO₂e/kWh, the corresponding illustrative emission-intensity range was approximately 88–113 kg CO₂e/ton. Decomposition analysis showed that the lower electricity intensity of the analyzed plant reduced emissions by approximately 13–57 kg CO₂e/ton relative to the product-matched European reference, whereas the higher Turkish grid emission factor increased them by approximately 67–86 kg CO₂e/ton, resulting in a net increase of approximately 29–54 kg CO₂e/ton. Relative to the estimated Türkiye sector-level reference, the approximately 242 kg CO₂e/ton reduction was entirely attributable to lower electricity intensity because both systems shared the same grid emission factor. Process assessment further indicated an 85% recycled-pulp ratio and a 64.3% steam-utilization ratio. Overall, the results demonstrate that comparatively low plant-level electricity consumption does not necessarily result in lower electricity-related CO₂e emissions when the electricity supply has a higher carbon intensity. The proposed framework provides a practical approach for distinguishing plant-level electricity-efficiency effects from electricity-grid carbon-intensity effects in paper-production benchmarking.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236801945
Cites: 17
Cited by:
Related to: 10