Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Health technology assessment (HTA) bodies are increasingly encouraged to adopt deliberative processes, yet the case for deliberation is too often left unspecified. It is not enough to say that a process was inclusive, consultative or transparent. We ask what it is that deliberation is supposed to improve in HTA and how institutions might recognize any such improvement. We propose four tests for judging whether deliberation has improved, or is likely to improve, an HTA decision, namely whether the decision is (i) more comprehensively evidence-informed, (ii) better matched to the context of application, (iii) more efficiently implementable and (iv) more widely acceptable to those affected by it, whether positively or negatively. The tests are output-side criteria for the decision itself. They complement rather than replace existing input-side guidance on the design of deliberative processes, and they permit prospective and retrospective comparison with plausible alternatives such as threshold rules alone, narrow expert appraisal and written consultation. We then identify four institutional conditions that make good deliberation more likely, treated as hypotheses about what makes decisions more likely to pass the tests: evidence and scoping quality, process quality, representational quality, and accountability and learning. Deliberation should not be praised as an inherent good. It must earn its place by helping HTA institutions make better reasoned, more defensible decisions.
Authors: Ahmet Küçükuncular, Anthony J. Culyer
Institutions: Near East University, University of York
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,550
OpenAlex ID: W7236810104
