Evidence-Based Environmental Policy Management in Riau Province
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article analyzes the management of evidence-based environmental policy in Riau Province, a region with vast tropical forests and peatlands that faces intense pressure from oil palm plantations, forestry, mining, and natural resource processing. Ecological problems—particularly recurrent forest and land fires—have accumulated since the New Order era due to resource exploitation, peatland conversion, and weak spatial planning oversight. Using a qualitative case study approach, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with purposively selected informants from environmental and development planning agencies, academics, and civil society organizations, complemented by documentary study and descriptive analysis of secondary statistical data (2015–2022) using source and technique triangulation. The findings show that evidence utilization in environmental policy formulation remains partial and not yet systematic: planning documents cite hotspot and critical land data, yet the depth of analysis and its linkage to policy choices are inconsistent. High-quality, easily accessible data—such as hotspot data (quality 4.3; utilization 4.1)—tends to be used, while socio-economic data (2.7; 2.4), site-level peat condition data (2.9; 2.6), and program evaluation data (2.5; 2.3) are underutilized. Burned area fluctuates sharply with climatic cycles, peaking in 2019 at 96,200 hectares, with peatlands consistently accounting for 54–68 percent of burned areas. Key obstacles include institutional fragmentation, limited analytical human resource capacity (only two to three technical staff per agency), weak institutionalization of cross-agency coordination forums, and unstructured knowledge transfer from research into policy. The study recommends establishing an integrated and authoritative data coordination architecture, strengthening the analytical capacity of government officials, and institutionalizing multi-stakeholder dialogue to promote more adaptive, accountable, and proactive environmental governance
Authors: Tamba Togap Tambun, Zulkarnaini
Institution: Riau University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDGs: Life on land, Climate action
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7236811429
