Clos(ur)e to professionalism? An international comparison of the effect of occupational closure on the income of adult educators
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The development of professionalism among adult educators is widely regarded as essential for ensuring the quality and effectiveness of adult learning and education (ALE) in the face of major societal challenges. However, employment conditions and institutional structures in the field remain heterogeneous and fragmented across Europe. The study investigates whether occupational closure – defined as the formal regulation of access to a profession – is associated with income differences among adult educators. Drawing on closure theory, we analyse two core closure sources: credentialism and standardisation. Using 10 waves (2011–2020) of the European Union Labour Force Survey (EU-LFS) and a sample of 55,728 adult educators from 24 countries, we apply multilevel Bayesian regression models to account for both individual and contextual variation. The results show no statistically significant effects either of credentialism or standardisation on income. Although the marginal effects indicate slight distributional tendencies across income deciles, these patterns remain limited. These findings challenge key assumptions of closure theory and highlight the limitations of formalised professionalisation strategies in weakly institutionalised fields like ALE. A broader perspective is needed – one that considers structural work conditions and supports inclusive and context-sensitive approaches to professional development.
Authors: Karoline Werner, Andreas Martin, Fabian Rüter
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7236830655
