Work

Beyond Official Statistics: An Assessment of State Failure in the Eradication of Manual Scavenging in India

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Manual scavenging remains a major test of the Indian state’s capacity to translate legal prohibition into substantive social change. This paper examines how the performance of government programmes should be assessed when a nationwide survey reports no identified manual scavengers, while hazardous sanitation work and related fatalities continue to raise public concern. The study adopts qualitative documentary analysis, drawing on government statements, statutory provisions, judicial decisions, and published research. It distinguishes manual scavenging as defined by law from hazardous cleaning of sewers and septic tanks, because the two categories are related but are not legally interchangeable. The analysis finds that official identification figures, rehabilitation assistance, training data, and recorded FIRs are important indicators of administrative activity; however, these outputs do not by themselves establish eradication, successful enforcement, or lasting occupational mobility. It further argues that death statistics must be interpreted in light of classification practices, reporting coverage, and the availability of case-level information. The paper also highlights a less visible dimension of the problem: occupational illness and delayed health consequences may remain difficult to connect to sanitation work in the absence of exposure histories and systematic occupational-health surveillance. These issues are inseparable from caste-based occupational marginalisation, which has historically restricted the livelihood choices of affected communities. The paper proposes an evidence-based framework for evaluating state performance through the completeness of identification, prevention, enforcement outcomes, rehabilitation results, occupational-health monitoring, and community participation. It concludes that claims of eradication require transparent methods, independent verification, and evidence that affected workers have secured safe and sustainable alternatives. The central measure of state success must therefore be the lived outcome for workers, rather than administrative declarations alone
Author: Bobby
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7236844786
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10