Work

Separation of a Distinction's Use From Its Articulation: How Practice Can Precede an Explicit Account

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This conceptual paper introduces Separation of a Distinction’s Use From Its Articulation, a distinction between the time a difference begins to guide choices and the time someone explicitly states it. Evidence of earlier use comes from dated, repeated choices made where the difference mattered. An explicit account has its own date and author. Sometimes the person who acted later explains the choice. In other cases, a later observer supplies the language for a practice already visible in the record. Robert Siegler and Elsbeth Stern studied how second graders in Munich solved arithmetic problems such as 35 + 8 − 8. Some children answered within four seconds, showed no visible sign of calculation, and then described adding and subtracting. In the group that received a mixture of problem types, 12 of 15 children showed this rapid response pattern before they first reported using the shortcut. The timing, observed behavior, and explanations allow the researchers to compare what a child did on a particular trial with what the child said about it. Jane Austen’s Emma appeared in December 1815. After Mr. Elton proposes to Emma, the exclamation “Such a blow for Harriet!” brings Emma’s voice into the narration without quotation marks. On the next page, Austen quotes Emma’s first-person thoughts directly. A collection of early essays on the distinction begins in 1894, and Charles Bally proposed the term style indirect libre in 1912. The passage preserves Austen’s choices. How she would have explained them remains open. Part of the Formation and Enactment series within On Human Modeling, the paper places the distinction alongside Michael Polanyi’s account of tacit knowledge. An editor reviewing AI-generated interview summaries might repeatedly restore quotation marks around a speaker’s exact words and remove them from paraphrases. Dated revisions could show when that distinction guided her editing. A later style guide could show when she put the rule in writing.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236846933
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10