Work

Does perception of climate change wait for a perceptible step? Results of a preregistered test of Route 1 of the Correction Freeze Problem in Eurobarometer, 2009 to 2023

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Route 1 of the Correction Freeze Problem (CFP; postulated by Professor Vuong Quan Hoang as a mathematical apparatus), the shifting-baseline ratchet, holds that a perceived state is corrected only when a single step in the true state clears a perceptibility threshold, so that warming arriving in small steps can accumulate without being registered. We tested this claim in perceived seriousness of climate change, against two rivals: a gap rule, under which correction is triggered by the warming accumulated since the last correction, and tracking, under which perception follows the state with no threshold. The test linked 218,189 respondents in eight Special Eurobarometer surveys (224 country-waves in 31 countries and areas, 2009 to 2023) to each country's monthly temperature history from the ERA5 reanalysis. Every prediction, falsifier and model was deposited on Zenodo before the survey data were downloaded. A simulation run before data access showed that a first design falsified Route 1 even when it was true, and the design was replaced before registration; the registered design recovered Route 1 in 95% of simulated datasets where it was true. Respondents were split into an exploration sample, used only to estimate the threshold, and a confirmatory sample, opened after that estimate was archived. The threshold was estimated at the bottom of the registered grid, 0.05 °C, with a bootstrap interval spanning the whole grid (0.05 to 0.30 °C). In the confirmatory sample, no falsifier fired. Warming registered under Route 1 raised the probability of rating climate change a very serious problem by 6.1 percentage points per °C (95% interval 1.5 to 10.4), but a threshold model fitted no better than tracking, and at a threshold of 0.05 °C almost every yearly step counts as a correction, so the two cannot be told apart. Route 1 is therefore not falsified but not supported. Perceived seriousness of climate change follows warming in a way best described as tracking. An exploratory analysis of the full 1 to 10 score gave the same pattern, with an increase of 0.33 points per °C. The exploratory test of hidden capture was not applicable, because almost no warming was left uncorrected.
Institution: Phenikaa University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236850080
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10