Ruled-Out Outcomes: False Certainty, the Overridden Faint Doubt, and Reactions to Outcomes Beyond Imagination
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: People are often certain about outcomes that are objectively uncertain. In this preprint I describe a sequence that I call the ruled-out outcome. A person, or a group, becomes certain of one outcome. A faint doubt pointing to another possibility appears and is overridden. The actual outcome then falls in the zone the mind had closed. I distinguish two forms of that closed zone. In the first, the outcome was dismissed: it was imagined and then rejected despite the doubt. In the second, it was never imagined: no mental picture of it existed at all. The distinction between expectations that are actively held and expectations that were never considered goes back to Ortony and Partridge (1987). What I add is the claim that the two forms lead to different reactions. Dismissed outcomes should mainly produce regret and self-blame ("I knew it!"). Never-imagined outcomes should mainly produce freezing, followed by misreading the outcome as one of the alternatives that had been imagined (force-fitting). I also propose that a doubt that was consciously felt and then overridden changes the known regret asymmetry for sticking with a first choice (Kruger et al., 2005), and that such doubts occur even in pure-chance tasks, where there is no correct answer for them to detect. I state seven testable propositions and outline a simple experiment based on a hidden-dice game.
Author: Bajpai, N. Shiney Vindhyesh
Language: English
Subfield: General Decision Sciences
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236860960
