Sanctions and Proportionality: Judicial Perspectives from the European Union and the United Kingdom
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Since Brexit, the United Kingdom has established an autonomous sanctions regime un-der the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018. This framework diverges sig-nificantly from that of the European Union in both scope and safeguards: designation criteria are broader, evidentiary thresholds are lower, and periodic review of individual listings is no longer required. These changes have shaped the way in which individu-al sanctions, particularly asset freezes, are contested before domestic courts. This arti-cle examines how UK and EU courts adjudicate fundamental rights challenges to such measures, focusing on the role of the proportionality principle in judicial review. While formally central to both legal systems, proportionality review has consistently been con-ducted with marked deference to executive discretion, exposing tensions between rights protection and foreign policy discretion. Two recent landmark judgments—those of the Court of Justice of the EU in Pumpyanskiy and the UK Supreme Court in Shvidler—have authoritatively addressed, at the highest judicial level in each system, how propor-tionality should be assessed in individual sanctions cases. Together, they provide the clearest statement yet of the limits courts are willing to impose on executive designation powers, and of the limits of proportionality itself as a safeguard for fundamental rights in the foreign policy domain.
Source: Zbornik znanstvenih razprav
Author: Marie Terlinden
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236862535
