Us, them, and the public broadcaster: group identification and bias perceptions toward public service media
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Prior research demonstrates that media bias perceptions are often rooted in social and political identification. However, most work focuses on partisan outlets. In Europe, public service media (PSM) are subject to bias accusations, despite their mandate to ensure pluralism and impartiality. This raises questions on whether frameworks explaining bias perceptions toward politically affiliated media apply to PSM. Building on insights from social identity theory and affective polarization, this study examines to what extent partisan in-group identification strength and strength of ideological and politicized societal out-group(s) antipathy are associated with bias perceptions toward PSM. Using original survey data ( N = 1863) from the Netherlands, I show that partisan in-group identification strength is not associated with bias perceptions toward PSM. Instead, the strength of ideological out-group antipathy is consistently associated with bias perceptions toward PSM and extends to politicized societal groups. Furthermore, the effects for the strength of ideological out-group antipathy are conditional on ideological self-placement and party support: it’s effect is primarily associated with bias perceptions among center- and right-leaning individuals and respondents who support right-leaning parties. Additionally, right-leaning and conservative respondents were overall more likely to perceive bias toward PSM. The findings of this paper advance hostile media and affective polarization research by demonstrating that ideological out-group antipathy and ideological predispositions are fundamental to understanding bias perceptions toward neutrality-bound institutions such as PSM. Together, bias perceptions toward PSM must not only be understood through hostility toward political opponents but also through broader ideological orientations through which audiences evaluate PSM’s impartiality.
Author: Emily Gravesteijn
Institutions: Radboud University Nijmegen, University of Amsterdam
Language: English
Topic: Media Influence and Politics
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,550
Funder: Radboud Universiteit
OpenAlex ID: W7236867075
