The Justiciability of the Right to Water: a Comparative Study of South Africa and India Grounded in Human Dignity and Equality
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Water is now widely accepted, both in international human rights law and in a growing number of national legal systems, as a human right in its own right. It cannot be separated from the rights to life, to health, to housing and to an adequate standard of living, and without it human dignity cannot be enjoyed on equal terms. This article asks how far that right can actually be enforced, and answers the question by comparison. It sets South Africa, where the right is written plainly into the Bill of Rights and can be taken to court, against India, where there is no such express guarantee and the right has instead been read into the right to life, even though the Directive Principles of State Policy from which it grows are not themselves enforceable. The discussion is organised around the building blocks of the human rights framework: the values of dignity, equality and non-discrimination; the content the right is understood to carry, that water be available, safe, acceptable, within reach and affordable; and the familiar threefold duty on the state to respect, protect and fulfil, to be met step by step and to the limit of what resources allow. Close attention is paid to how the courts handle the right, to the standard of review the South African Constitutional Court has chosen and what it means for holding the state to account, and to the long-running disagreement between the international idea of a minimum core and the South African preference for reasonableness. The argument is that recognising the right in the constitution, whether directly or by inference, matters a great deal for whether it can be vindicated, and that a human rights approach rooted in dignity and equality offers the firmer ground for protecting it, above all for the poor and marginalised, who feel its absence most.
Source: Ayika.
Author: Hlako Choma
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236964182
