Work

Escaping the understanding-assent links impasse

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This paper provides an account of radical deviance, of what a speaker must do that would require us to translate her words non-homophonically. The account comes in two parts. The first argues that the appropriate unit of analysis for radical deviance is not a speaker’s utterance of individual sentences considered in isolation from her dealings with other speakers, but her contribution to a meaning-giving dialectic considered as a whole. The second argues that a speaker’s use of a word counts as radically deviant if only if it involves a refusal either (1) to engage in or (2) to respect the meaning-giving dialectic for that word. This account has two important consequences. First, it resolves a longstanding issue with semantic externalism, namely, that of explaining what a speaker must do to get thrown out of the social practice her participation in which secures for her words the meanings they have. Second, it provides a new contribution to the debate over the understanding-assent links thesis, according to which some sentences p are such that, necessarily, whoever understands p assents to p. Williamson (2007, 2012/2020) has argued that there are no such links. Boghossian (2012/2020) and Warren (2021) take themselves to have provided counterexamples to Williamson’s argument. Whether one considers these counterexamples to be genuine, however, is a matter of intuition. Thus the debate is at an impasse. The account of radical deviance proposed here provides a way out.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,190
OpenAlex ID: W7236998131
FWCI:
Cites: 20
Cited by:
Related to: 10