Work

AI leadership readiness profiles and competence gaps among school leaders during digital transformation: a comparative study of China and Kazakhstan

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) has become a school-level governance issue during digital transformation, yet how school leaders translate instructional judgments into implementation readiness remains insufficiently understood. This cross-national study examined AI leadership readiness in China and Kazakhstan, focusing on scenario understanding, instructional value, risk concern, digital leadership self-efficacy, organizational support, leadership support for adoption, implementation readiness, and competence gaps. Methods We analyzed a cross-national quantitative survey of 763 school leaders (China n = 389; Kazakhstan n = 374) using reliability analysis, measurement invariance testing, latent profile analysis, standardized recursive path modeling, and importance–competence gap analysis. Results Internal consistency was adequate for most constructs; AI-related risk concern was lower (α = 0.581, ω = 0.582). Scalar invariance met conventional fit-change criteria, and observed composite scores were higher among Chinese respondents for scenario understanding, instructional value, leadership support, digital leadership self-efficacy, and implementation readiness, whereas risk concern was higher among Kazakhstani respondents. The retained four-profile solution comprised high understanding–high readiness, value-positive–near-average readiness, risk-sensitive cautious, and low understanding–low readiness. Scenario understanding was positively associated with instructional value (β = 0.585); instructional value was positively associated with leadership support (β = 0.339); and digital leadership self-efficacy was positively associated with implementation readiness (β = 0.328). The largest importance–competence gaps concerned ethics and risk governance ( G = 1.75), teacher development ( G = 1.58), and content quality audit ( G = 1.56). Discussion Positive instructional appraisals frequently coexisted with moderate school-level preparation. Implementation readiness was most closely associated with digital leadership self-efficacy, organizational support, and leadership support for adoption. Ethics and risk governance, teacher development, and content quality audit emerged as the leading priorities for professional learning.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,801
OpenAlex ID: W7237168223
FWCI:
Cites: 46
Cited by:
Related to: 10
Parts: 3