Exercise delivery strategies and functional outcomes in community-dwelling older adults: A systematic review and network meta-analysis
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Evidence comparing structured exercise delivery strategies for community-dwelling older adults remains uncertain. We compared Home, Remote, Face, and Hybrid delivery with Control for functional outcomes, trial withdrawal, and safety. We systematically searched six databases through 8 October 2026 and performed frequentist random-effects network meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials. Outcomes were Timed Up and Go (TUG), 10–12-week time-based static standing balance, exact 12-week all-cause trial withdrawal, and adverse events. Adverse events were principally synthesized descriptively. Sensitivity analyses assessed event definitions, time windows, uncertain balance denominators, and cluster-randomized designs. Evidence confidence was assessed using CINeMA.Results: The review included 684 reports from 625 independent trials; 146 reports contributed to at least one quantitative analysis. The TUG, balance, withdrawal, and comparative adverse-event evidence sets comprised 37 trials/39 comparisons, 12/14, 55/61, and 26/28, respectively. Compared with Control, TUG mean differences favored Remote (1.015 s, 95% CI 0.417–1.613), Face (1.057 s, 0.556–1.558), and Hybrid (1.014 s, 0.297–1.731); Home was uncertain (0.781 s, −0.026–1.589). TUG heterogeneity was substantial (I²=58.0%), with global inconsistency (P=0.0087). Balance point estimates versus Control ranged from SMD 0.429 to 0.595. Brown_2000 was excluded from the primary balance analysis because outcome-specific denominators were unverified. For exact 12-week withdrawal, Home had higher risk than Control (RR 1.544, 95% CI 1.175–2.027); the direction persisted across broader time-window analyses. Withdrawal heterogeneity was 0%, with no detected global inconsistency (P=0.635). Adverse-event evidence was sparse and inconsistently ascertained. Remote, Face, and Hybrid showed modest favorable short-term TUG estimates versus Control, but all 10 TUG comparisons had very low confidence, and heterogeneity, inconsistency, and small-study asymmetry limit interpretation. No delivery strategy was consistently superior. Home showed higher exact 12-week trial withdrawal, although broader windows included different trials. Comparative safety remains uncertain CRD420261432283 Not applicable
Source: BMC Geriatrics
Authors: Kaiqi Wang, Junhao He, Anjing Zhu, Xuecui Bi
Institution: Capital University of Physical Education and Sports
Language: English
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,190
OpenAlex ID: W7237189062
