Mirrored Suspicion: Conspiracy, Securitization, and the Opposition to Jewish–Muslim Engagement in the United States since 9/11
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Since September 11, 2001, efforts to build durable relationships between American Jewish and American Muslim communities have met organized opposition from within both communities. This article argues that the opposition follows a logic of mirrored suspicion: opponents of engagement in each community read the other’s outreach as a surface concealing hostile intent. The form that suspicion takes, however, tracks each community’s position relative to the American security state. Among American Muslims, opposition tends toward a conspiratorial register in which interfaith programs, particularly those connected to Zionist institutions, are read as covert normalization, surveillance, or co-optation. Among American Jews, opposition tends toward a securitizing register in which Muslim partners are read as fronts for Islamist networks or for a “red-green” convergence of Islamism and the radical left. Drawing on peer-reviewed research in social psychology, the sociology of religion, security studies, and digital religion, and on five episodes from 2001 to 2024, the article shows that the two registers share a narrative grammar of concealment and exposure, that both are concentrated in organizational and online arenas rather than in lay opinion, and that digital platforms reward them. It proposes symmetrical criteria for distinguishing principled dissent from suspicion and outlines a research design for testing the argument. Mirrored suspicion, the article concludes, is a structural obstacle to pluralism that neither community can dismantle alone.
Source: Research Square
Author: Iqbal Akhtar
Institution: Florida International University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237216182
