Work

Evolutionary Proofs: Antinomy-Driven Ratcheted Verification Escalation, Revocation Semilattices, and Domain-Separated Dual Sandboxing (v2.2)

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This conceptual position paper (v2.2) introduces Evolutionary Proofs, an antinomy-driven, ratcheted verification escalation architecture designed to move cryptographic verification beyond static trust regimes (hardware enclaves, remote attestation, pairing-based SNARKs, or fixed post-quantum STARKs) without exposing protocols to man-in-the-middle downgrade attacks. Drawing conceptually on Thomas Kesselring's formal-dialectical reconstruction of Kantian–Hegelian antinomies and Piagetian developmental transitions, the framework models cryptographic and execution-isolation retirement as a join-semilattice of monotonically growing revocation sets ($\mathcal{B}_t = \mathcal{B}_t^{\text{proof}} \cup \mathcal{B}_t^{\text{iso}}$) over atomic, versioned mechanism identifiers, paired with explicit ADMIT, REVOKE, and CHECKPOINT records and composite $k$-of-$n$ multi-prover policies. Core Contributions: STH-Backed MMR Ratchet: Commits $\mathcal{B}_t$ and $\mathcal{M}_t$ digests inside a threshold-signed Signed Tree Head (STH) over an append-only Merkle Mountain Range (MMR), preserving $O(\log t)$ consistency proofs ($\pi_{\text{mmr}}$), append-only auditability, and deterministic derivation of role-specific active sets ($\mathcal{A}_{\text{prover}}$, $\mathcal{A}_{\text{verifier}}$, $\mathcal{A}_{\text{iso}}$). Generalized Transcript Binding & Downgrade Game: Extends transcript binding ($T_t$) to both interactive P2P sessions and non-interactive public verifiers (e.g., Zcash, Ethereum), supported by a conceptual downgrade game ($\text{Exp}^{\text{down}}_{\mathcal{A}}$), an explicit informal advantage bound, and candid accounting of governance equivocation and the fourth Schranke (ratchet primitives outside $\mathcal{M}_t$). Domain-Separated Dual Sandbox & Sanitizer Bridge: Couples the ratchet to an Online Edge / Offline Core / Ephemeral Offline Staging execution plane with a bounded-TCB AG-ZKP Sanitizer bridge outside Domain 1, including a mechanism-specific sanitization matrix distinguishing re-randomizable SNARKs from non-malleable STARKs and TEE attestations. Explicit Threat Boundaries: Candidly documents safety vs. liveness nuances, omission/freeze bounds ($\Delta T + T_{\text{chk}}$ and fail-closed reboot rules), coarse-window linkability trade-offs, cold-start eclipse, Domain 1 rollback, the TEE-to-ZK witness leakage trap, and the remote verifiability gap of software sandboxes. Scope & Transparency: This document is a conceptual position paper and architectural blueprint—not an empirical benchmark or mechanized proof. Large language models (Gemini and Claude) were used transparently as iterative sparring partners, critical reviewers, and drafting assistants. Released under CC BY 4.0.
Author: Atakan, Mert
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237217032
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10