Work

Beyond Knowledge Transmission: Muslim Intellectual Contributions and the Dynamics of Islam–West Knowledge Circulation

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study aims to analyze the paradigms of Muslim contributions to modern Western thought, identify the internal and external factors shaping these contributions, and examine their implications for science and technology. Using a qualitative integrative literature review, the study synthesizes 20 Indonesian scholarly articles published between 2016 and 2025. Data were examined through qualitative content analysis involving coding, categorization, and cross-source comparison. Harold D. Lasswell’s communication framework was applied to interpret intellectual actors, knowledge content, transmission channels, receiving communities, and consequences. The findings identify four paradigms: historical mediation, responses to modernity, integration of rationality, and continuous intellectual renewal. Ten formative factors comprise five internal factors related to intellectual renewal, educational capacity, and engagement with tradition, and five external factors associated with historical encounters, colonialism, Western rationalism, globalization, and modernity. Six categories of implications include three positive intellectual contributions and three problematic conditions arising in changing historical contexts. The analysis further identifies two interconnected patterns of knowledge circulation: trans-civilizational circulation, involving the development and transformation of Islamic knowledge within European intellectual settings, and reflexive circulation, involving intellectual renewal within Muslim societies in response to Western modernity. The study contributes a contextual application of Lasswell’s framework, demonstrating that Islam–West intellectual relations involve active recipients, multiple transmission channels, and historically contingent processes of knowledge production, adaptation, and transformation rather than linear one-way transmission.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7237218641
FWCI:
Cites: 17
Cited by:
Related to: 10