Work

Legislative Silence on Transition and Legal Certainty in the 2026 Indian GST Intermediary Services Amendment

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: India's Finance Act 2026 omitted section 13(8)(b) of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act 2017 with effect from 30 March 2026, ending a decade of litigation over whether intermediary services supplied to foreign clients are exports. The amendment says nothing about disputes already pending, and this paper uses that silence as a case study in how legislatures should manage legal transitions. Its doctrinal argument is that the effect of an omission on pending proceedings is currently determined by a combination of factors: the form of the omitted provision, the nature of the proceeding (an accrued liability or a refund claim), section 6 of the General Clauses Act 1897, and any contrary intention. The Supreme Court has held that omitting a rule takes pending proceedings with it (Rayala, Kolhapur and, in August 2026, Goodluck India on rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules), whereas the line beginning with Fibre Boards treats the omission of a provision from an Act as a repeal to which section 6 applies. The paper does not claim that this distinction mechanically decides every dispute under section 13(8)(b), or that the amendment is unconstitutional. It argues that the combination leaves the transitional position uncertain, that the uncertainty flows from legislative silence rather than a considered choice, and that this is a cost to legal certainty and the rule of law. It keeps apart three questions, namely a constitutional challenge to the amendment, the interpretive question and the normative critique of drafting, and uses Article 14 case law on fiscal cutoff dates only as a lens for the third. It treats the law and economics literature on legal transitions as the source of a hypothesis, not a demonstrated efficiency result; analyses the reverse charge liability the amendment creates as a tax incidence problem that bites mainly where input tax credit is restricted; and draws limited design comparisons with EU VAT and Singapore GST. It proposes a model transitional provision covering the operation date, pending proceedings, finalised assessments, refunds, limitation and optional settlement, and explains what an administrative circular can and cannot achieve.
Language: English
Subfield: Accounting
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237224906
Cites: 16
Cited by:
Related to: 10