Work

Does a Dip in Heart Rate Variability Predict Cognitive Errors? A Preregistered Within-Person Null Result on the CLAS Dataset

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The BEP (Belonging–Energy–Prediction) framework treats heart rate variability (HRV) as an observable index of Energy, the regulatory capacity available for effortful cognition. A direct implication is that, within a person, moments of lower HRV should carry more cognitive errors, and that errors made during such moments should be “slips” the person recovers from on the next question. This preprint tests that implication on the public CLAS dataset (ECG recorded while adults solved math, logic and Stroop questions, with per-answer scoring), with three predictions written and fingerprinted (SHA-256) before any analysis. HRV was measured as RMSSD over the 30 seconds of ECG ending at each answer and standardized within each person. Result: a clean null. Across 58 participants and 3,771 scored answers, lower HRV did not predict errors (odds ratio per 1 SD lower HRV = 1.01, 95% CI 0.93–1.11); errors made at low HRV were not followed by more recoveries (59.8% vs 59.8%); and the effect was not consistent across tasks. All three predictions failed. The result constrains moment-to-moment HRV as a marker of momentary cognitive performance. It does not test BEP's central physiological prediction — that Energy governs which inferential policy is selected (evidence updating versus coherence seeking) — which remains open. Files: the preprint (PDF); predictions.txt, the verbatim preregistered text (SHA-256 ce50e4143e77d90eebf71958db39eaae6c44a780620f1dde55f16373546997db); hrv_clas_analysis.py, the analysis code; results.json, all reported numbers and processing counts. Data: CLAS (Markova et al., doi:10.17632/8hm59ryzb8.1, CC BY 4.0).
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237225900
Cites: 4
Cited by:
Related to: 10