Assessing Creativity in Mathematical Modeling Solutions Produced by ChatGPT and Preservice Teachers
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Creativity, a core 21st-century competency, is especially important in mathematical modeling because modeling requires mathematically sound, original, useful, and plausible solutions to real-world problems. The emergence of large language models raises questions about how established creativity indicators apply to artificial intelligence (AI)-generated modeling products. In this study, we analyzed written solutions produced by 140 preservice teachers (PSTs) and one archived zero-shot ChatGPT response per task using a modeling-specific framework based on fluency, originality, and usefulness. We examined three complex modeling tasks: cover-up, sand carrier, and eclipse. The PST corpus served as the task-specific reference distribution, while ChatGPT outputs were positioned descriptively within these distributions rather than treated as estimates of general or stable AI performance. Findings showed strong task dependence and a substantial floor effect on the eclipse task, with many PSTs providing incomplete or uninformative responses. Under the specified settings, three ChatGPT solutions ranked highly within the PST score distributions, primarily because their approaches were judged useful and coherent. Some PST solutions exhibited broader strategic variation and several original approaches, although these were often underdeveloped or undermined by validation errors. Fluency also varied across tasks, with the eclipse task eliciting the fewest complete approaches. These condition-specific findings suggest that creativity in modeling is best understood as a multidimensional, task-sensitive profile rather than a single performance measure. They also highlight complementary creativity patterns in PST- and ChatGPT-produced solutions and their potential for AI-supported modeling pedagogy in teacher education, especially for orchestrating and critically evaluating AI-generated solutions.
Authors: Mustafa Cevikbas, Xiaoli Lu, Gabriele Kaiser
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7237250886
