Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The Trump administration’s 2025 decision to embrace a Biden-era open access mandate invites the question: Are such mandates progressive, as most of us in libraries assume? Free sharing of the products of research, mainly publications and data, has arguably been the most prominent embodiment of the ongoing push for open science (OS). UNESCO (2023) has highlighted equity, fairness, diversity, and inclusiveness as values of OS; these are values that the present U.S. government explicitly opposes. In this commentary, we share a philosophical perspective on OS, introduced by Sabina Leonelli in a 2023 monograph, that provides a framework for understanding the political flexibility of sharing initiatives. Leonelli proposed an alternative model for OS, one that focuses on research processes rather than products. This model is better positioned to fulfill OS’s promise of increasing epistemic diversity in science. We also consider what a process-oriented view of OS would mean for libraries in practice.
Authors: Cay del Junco, Wynn Tranfield
Institutions: University of Toronto, University of California, Santa Cruz
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7237263233
