Husserl and Blaustein on Image Consciousness, Phantasy, and Pictorial Representation
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article investigates the problem of pictorial representation, which has been studied by Husserl along the lines of image consciousness. The latter was criticized by Blaustein, an understudied student of Husserl’s. Husserl’s image consciousness and Blaustein’s criticism bring to the fore a widespread polemic in analytic philosophy: the Wollheim–Walton debate and its underlying perception–imagination dichotomy. The foregoing analytic debate serves as both a background and an interpretative framework for the current article’s objectives. That is to say, this article delves into Husserl’s image consciousness and the question of imagination (phantasy) as presented in Ideas I and Husserliana , vol. 23, concluding with an appraisal of Blaustein’s criticism of Husserl. The Wollheim–Walton debate not only facilitates the article’s analyses but also serves to test the commonplace interpretations of Husserl’s and Blaustein’s accounts of pictorial depiction as being Wollheimian. As far as Blaustein’s imagination-based criticism is concerned, it can be dismissed on account of the aforementioned perception–imagination dichotomy, for Husserl – like Wollheim – is predominantly perceptualist. Regarding Blaustein’s symbol-based criticism, I argue that it is apt, as far as Ideas I is concerned; however, Husserliana , vol. 23 leaves no room for doubt as to whether Husserl took into consideration the question of symbol consciousness, especially as it pertains to image consciousness.
Source: Husserl Studies
Author: Hicham Jakha
Institution: Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,290
OpenAlex ID: W7237337802
