Work

The Language Tax: Comparative Transparency, Language Shift and Linguistic Justice in AI-Mediated Learning

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Generative AI systems perform less well in many languages than in English, and learners who notice this often respond by switching to English. Earlier work proposed comparative transparency, making such quality gaps visible to learners, as a remedy for unequal access to AI-mediated explanation, but left open whether transparency might accelerate the very language shift that narrows learners' interpretive resources. This conceptual paper takes up that unresolved problem. I introduce the concept of a language tax: the epistemic cost that learners whose language is not English pay whichever way they choose, either accepting weaker explanations in their own language or obtaining better explanations at the price of working outside the language and frames through which they understand. I argue that the injustice lies in the existence of the tax rather than in the learner's choice, and that switching to English, although rational for each learner, generates a collective dynamic of language shift that no individual can reverse. I then show that leading theories of linguistic justice, including Van Parijs's account of parity of esteem and Patten's account of equal recognition, address the status and rights of languages but not the epistemic position of learners who depend on AI. In response I propose a standard of linguistic epistemic parity, which pairs transparency with obligations to reduce quality gaps and with translanguaging pedagogies that allow learners to use English-language outputs without abandoning their own interpretive frames. The case of Arabic, where the diglossic gap between Modern Standard Arabic and spoken dialects complicates the very idea of a learner's own language, is used to test the account.
Author: Basal, Mona
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237338658
Cites: 2
Cited by:
Related to: