Dependent Reports Miscounted as Independent Corroboration: Why Five Reports Can Be One Source
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This conceptual paper introduces Dependent Reports Miscounted as Independent Corroboration, a structural constraint in the Sources and Evidentiary Limits series of On Human Modeling. Reports with different authors and publication dates can agree because they share an observation, a premise, a method, or an earlier conclusion. The paper asks where each account obtained its information and what its author checked. A reporter who draws on an earlier account can still add evidence by examining a detail firsthand. In 2009, shortly after the composer Maurice Jarre died, Dublin student Shane Fitzgerald added a quotation of his own invention to Jarre’s Wikipedia entry. Versions appeared in obituaries in Britain, India, and Australia. Wikipedia editors removed the passage three times. The Guardian, which had opened its obituary with a shorter version, later identified the Wikipedia insertion as the probable source. The surviving records show where the quotation appeared, while the route it took to each of the other publications remains open. In 2008, a teenager added “Brazilian aardvark” to Wikipedia’s entry for the coati, a member of the raccoon family. He later said he had invented the nickname. By 2014, the entry cited a 2010 article in The Telegraph as support for it. A dated revision shows that an editor removed both the nickname and the citation. The footnote establishes that Wikipedia used the newspaper as a source. Where the newspaper obtained the name, and whether anyone had used it before the teenager’s edit, remain open. The paper places the constraint alongside Ludwig Wittgenstein’s comparison to buying several copies of the morning paper to check whether its story is true. A similar question arises when an AI assistant cites five articles reporting that a council vote was unanimous. If all five draw on the same press release, the citations trace back to one account of the vote. A reporter who also checked the recorded roll call contributes something further, and the reader can identify exactly what that check adds.
Author: Cary, Alexandra
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237339486
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
