When goals collide: National-level practitioner perspectives on traffic safety and other transport-policy objectives
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study examines how national-level practitioners perceive synergies and tensions between traffic safety and other transport-policy objectives in Sweden. Although the burden of traffic accidents in Sweden has decreased, the decline has plateaued in recent years. To maintain momentum towards the 2030 interim targets and Vision Zero—the ambition that no one should be killed or seriously injured within the transport system—it may be necessary to utilise a more integrated approach and emphasise traffic safety’s potential to contribute to broader societal challenges, such as climate and equality. Seventeen strategists and experts at the Swedish Transport Administration were interviewed, representing traffic safety, health, mobility, environmental sustainability, social sustainability, and national planning. The interviews were analysed using qualitative content analysis, with the conflict-management triangle applied to interpret the substantive, procedural, and relational dimensions of the tensions. Participants generally supported a more integrated approach but raised questions about its reciprocity and implications for traffic safety’s established focus. The analysis identified interactions that were described as predominantly synergistic, broadly compatible desired outcomes with implementation tensions, and persistent measure-specific trade-offs. Many tensions arose not from incompatible goals but from how broadly supported objectives were operationalised through measures, standards, evidence requirements, appraisal practices, and the distribution of benefits and disadvantages. The findings show that traffic safety’s alignment with sustainability and mobility depends on how it is operationalised. Advancing a more integrated approach requires distinguishing between tensions that may be addressed through changes in implementation and persistent trade-offs that need to be recognised and managed transparently.
Institutions: Lund University, Institute of Transport Economics
Language: English
Topic: Traffic and Road Safety
Subfield: Safety, Risk, Reliability and Quality
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,400
OpenAlex ID: W7237357264
