Work

False alarms and missed events in home monitoring: costs for caregivers and for the people they care for

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Home monitoring systems for older people or people with dementia make two kinds of error: they give false alarms and they miss real events. This note examines how often this happens in real-world use, what the two errors cost caregivers and cared-for people, and whether the sources allow us to say when an unreliable system is worse than no system. In the few studies with real falls that were found, automatic detectors miss some falls and produce false alarms in very variable numbers; in one pilot study a wearable device gave 83 false alarms out of 84. In a cohort of people over 90, a push-button alarm was almost always present, but in most falls it was not used. In a US trial some caregivers moved the sensors after false alarms; according to the authors, many switched off the sensors or did not use the alerts to change daily care. A synthesis of 20 laboratory experiments estimates that, below a reliability of about 70%, diagnostic automation gives worse results than no automation. No study found shows, in the home, an unreliable system with worse outcomes than no system; in the two controlled trials available the system was not worse. The risk conditions and the measures proposed are our interpretations.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237364007
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: