The Dhammasaṅgaṇī Mātikā 164-Partition Lattice, Nippadesa/Sappadesa Closure, and Rūpa-kaṇḍa Epistemic Audit: Fulfilling S2-P32 Prediction #2 Across the Type/Moment Dichotomy under Machine Verification
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: ## Abstract Across `S2-P31` (*Yamaka*), `S2-P32` (*Dhātukathā*), `S2-P33` (*Kathāvatthu*), `S2-P34` (*Puggalapaññatti*), and the comparative northern bridge `S2-P35` (*Abhidharmakośabhāṣya*), five treatises of the *Abhidhamma* corpus received executable Epistemic Life Engine v4.1 (`epistemic_v4.1_harness`) verification. Yet **Book I of the Theravāda *Abhidhamma Piṭaka*, the *Dhammasaṅgaṇī***, had previously only been anchored at the level of its constituent *paramattha* token sets ($89$ *cittas*, $52$ *cetasikas*, $28$ *rūpas*, and *Nibbāna*) and its $89 \times 52$ *sampayoga* matrix (`Paper 1`, `S2-P2`, `S2-P3`, `S2-P32`). Consequently, in `S2-P32` (Prediction #2), we registered an explicit falsifiable program: formalize the complete **164-*Mātikā* matrix** ($22$ *Tikas* + $100$ *Abhidhamma Dukas* + $42$ *Suttanta Dukas*) and the ***Rūpa-kaṇḍa*** (`ekavidhena` through `ekādasavidhena`) directly on top of `U_170` and `DhatukathaNayaEngine`—without duplicating `S2-P2` or `S2-P32`—and audit every partition for formal logical completeness, implicational closure, type-vs.-moment scope ambiguity, and zero-free-parameter structural integrity. Submitting the complete *Dhammasaṅgaṇī Mātikā* and *Rūpa-kaṇḍa* architecture to [`test_dhammasangani_matika_epistemic_audit.py`](file:///C:/Users/dharm/Desktop/Epistemic%20Life%20Engine/epistemic_v4.1_harness/benchmarks/test_dhammasangani_matika_epistemic_audit.py) establishes six audited results across two canonical *cittuppāda* expansion sizes ($\mathcal{U}_{2464} = 89 + 2346 + 28 + 1$ and $\mathcal{U}_{3576} = 121 + 3426 + 28 + 1$): - **Theorem DS.I (Layer 0 Z3 *Nippadesa/Sappadesa* Dichotomy Across 22 *Tikas*, 100 *Dukas*, & 121-*Citta* Invariance).** Over all 22 canonical triads (*Tikas*, `Ds 1.1`), Z3 SMT equivalence checking proves **13 exhaustive disjoint 3-way partitions (*nippadesa*)** and **9 partial triads (*sappadesa*)** (`#2, #6, #7, #13, #16, #17, #18, #19, #21`), matching Buddhaghosa's *Atthasālinī* (`PTS 45–48`) identically on both $\mathcal{U}_{2464}$ and $\mathcal{U}_{3576}$. In every single *sappadesa* triad, *Nibbāna* lies in the non-empty uncovered remainder (`nibbana_in_remainder = true`), accompanied by self-excluded mental factors (`vedanā`, `vitakka`, `pīti`) or *rūpa* elements. Across all **100 *Abhidhamma Dukas*** (`Ds 1.2`), Z3 formalization proves **exact `70` union-exhaustive dyads**—comprising **69 disjoint Boolean complements** ($P_1 \sqcup P_2 = \mathcal{U}$) plus **1 overlapping union-exhaustive dyad** (*Kenaci viññeyyā / na viññeyyā*, $P_1 \cup P_2 = \mathcal{U}, P_1 \cap P_2 \neq \emptyset$)—and **30 strictly non-exhaustive *gocchaka* conjunction dyads** (`8 × 3 + 2 + 4 = 30`). We explicitly flag and resolve the famous printed *Atthasālinī/Mohavicchedanī* textual crux where `ekasattati` (`71`) appears twice against `100` (`70/30` formal logic vs. `71/29` commentarial counting). Furthermore, `EpistemicProvenanceLedger` enforces `ABSTAIN_UNDERSPECIFIED` when a variable *cetasika* type (*phassa*) is queried for a unique *Kusalattika* limb without closing its quantifier scope (`TYPE_OVERLAP` vs. `CITTUPPADA_MOMENT`). [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Theorem DS.II (Layer 0 *Parāmāsa* 5-Dyad Singleton Theorem & the *Gocchaka* / *Sāsava* Lattice).** Projecting the 10 canonical *gocchakas* onto `ALL_52_CETASIKAS` (`Ds Nikkhepakaṇḍa`) separates canonical *aspect counts* (`Hetu = 6`, `Āsava = 4`, `Saṃyojana = 10`, `Gantha = 4`, `Ogha = 4`, `Yoga = 4`, `Nīvaraṇa = 6`, `Parāmāsa = 1`, `Upādāna = 4`, `Kilesa = 10`) from distinct `ALL_52_CETASIKAS` basis projections (`6, 3, 8, 3, 3, 3, 8, 1, 2, 10`), disambiguating `kāmacchanda-nīvaraṇa = lobha` (`Ds 1154`) from morally neutral `chanda`. Z3 proves zero self-associated witnesses (`self_sampayutta_witnesses_count = 0`) for ***Parāmāsa*** ($\{\text{diṭṭhi}\}$, cardinality 1) across all 2,464 instances while every other *gocchaka* has non-zero self-association (`8` to `185`), proving why canonical `Ds 1.2` contains **5** *Parāmāsa* dyads rather than 6. Z3 also verifies the strict *cetasika* root poset and the exact object-predicate quotient `sāsava = saṃyojaniya = ganthaniya = oghaniya = yoganiya = nīvaraṇiya = parāmaṭṭha = upādāniya = saṅkilesika = lokiya = pariyāpanna = sa-uttara` (`0` mismatches across $\mathcal{U}_{2464}$), alongside `saraṇa = saṅkiliṭṭha = akusala` (`0` mismatches). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Theorem DS.III (*S2-P32* Prediction #2 14-*Naya* Closure, *Rūpa-kaṇḍa* 1–11 Conservation, & 42 *Suttanta Dukas* Firewall).** Running `DhatukathaNayaEngine.run_all_14_nayas` over 10 representative *Mātikā* subsets fulfills `S2-P32` Prediction #2 cleanly, distinguishing *saṅkhārakkhandha* *gocchakas* (`141` `samp_of_samp`), *oḷārika rūpas* (`10` hit *āyatanas*), `lokuttara` *cittas* (`manāyatana`), and *Nibbāna* (`0` *khandhas*). Auditing *Rūpa-kaṇḍa* (`Ds 2.2`, `ekavidhena`–`ekādasavidhena`) verifies exact 28-*rūpa* conservation across every structural cut (`4 + 24`, `12 + 16`, `5 + 23`, `18 + 10`, `9 + 9 + 10` *upādiṇṇa* split, `[1, 1, 1, 1, 24]`, `[8, 20]`, and `11` *āyatana* bins summing to `28`). Partitioning all 42 *Suttanta Dukas* (`Ds 1.3`) yields **18** direct *paramattha–cetasika* dyads and **24** *paññatti*/monastic/praxis-boundary dyads (`18 + 24 = 42`). [Tier M1; Tier B2.]- **Theorem DS.IV (Layer $-1$ Farkas Impossibility Proofs & Layer 2b Zero-DOF Colimit with Two Red-Team Controls).** `AutonomousDeadlockScout` + `IndependentUnsatChecker` emit exact rational `Fraction` Farkas certificates killing three impossible *Mātikā* claims (*Nibbāna* inside *saṅkhata*, *rūpa* inside *sārammaṇa*, and a 6th self-associated *Parāmāsa* dyad) and Filter A rejects unanchored heuristic trade-offs. Fusing `Dhammasangani_Tika_22_Domain`, `Dhammasangani_Duka_100_Gocchaka_Domain`, and `Rupakanda_28_And_Suttanta_42_Domain` in `MultiSpanColimitEngine` passes all five `PostPushoutVerifier` gates (`ASSUMED = 0`, `net_free_dof = 0`, `Phi_syn = 1.0`, `connected_components = 1`, pre-pinned SHA-256 `821dd8dd72714791...`, $3/3$ Farkas mutation kills). Appending either an uncoupled `E8_Matika_164_Numerology_Slot` or a `Suttanta_Bala_Pandita_Pannatti_Slot` fails Gate 5 fail-closed (`phi_syn_score = 0.0`). [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Theorem DS.V (SymPy Algebraic Identity, Layer 6 SAT Manifold, & Four Zero-Z3 DPLL Resolution Refutations).** SymPy symbolically confirms zero residual across the $8 \times (3+3) + (3+2) + (4+4) + 7 + 14 + 18 = 100$ *duka* partition identity and total $164$. A 10-variable, 18-clause structural *Mātikā* CNF matches brute-force $2^{10} = 1024$ enumeration identically (`20` models, `overlap_mean = 0.227368`, `shattering_barrier = 3.0`), and four standalone pure-Python DPLL + explicit Resolution proofs (`VALID_RESOLUTION_REFUTATION`) refute *Nibbāna*-*saṅkhata*, *rūpa*-*sārammaṇa*, *citta*-*cittasampayutta*, and *lokuttara*-*saṅkiliṭṭha*. [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Proposition DS.VI (Active Rule Discovery Across Ambiguous Macroscopic Counts).** Testing 4 competing matrix hypotheses in `ActiveRuleDiscoverer` confirms that coarse totals ($22, 100, 42 = 164$) leave all hypotheses indistinguishable (`AMBIGUOUS_HYPOTHESIS_CLASS`, `4` surviving), whereas 3 canonical probes (*Nibbāna* in *Vedanāttika*, *Parāmāsa* cardinality, and Gate-5 *Suttanta* coupling) isolate `H1_CANONICAL_DS_MATIKA_LATTICE` in `probes_used = 3` (`METAMORPHIC_PASS`). [Tier M2; Tier B2.]
Author: Oo, Myo
Language: English
Topic: Indian and Buddhist Studies
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7237364971
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
