Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: In Schriro v. Summerlin,l the Supreme Court held by a five-to-four margin that the rules announced in Ring v. Arizona 2 and Apprendi v. New Jersey 3 will not apply retroactively on collateral review of cases finally decided prior to those decisions.Thus, although the Supreme Court has declared the sentencing scheme under which Warren Summerlin was sentenced to death unconstitutional, Summerlin's sentence will stand because he exhausted all of his direct appeals before the Court nullified the sentencing scheme.This Note will argue that Schriro is indefensible: the decision is a jurisprudential failure that misconstrues the relevant precedent in the areas of the Sixth Amendment, habeas retroactivity, and the Eighth Amendment.Further, Justice Scalia's majority opinion privileges finality over justice and makes a virtue out of federal deference to unconstitutional state court decisions and laws.Finally, there is no compelling policy justification for the decision.Rather, as Justice Breyer noted in'dissent, the retroactive application of Ring and Apprendi would only minimally disrupt state criminal justice systems.For all of these reasons, the Court should overrule itself and reject Schriro as soon as possible. II. BACKGROUNDThe Court confronted a seemingly straightforward question in Schriro: "whether Ring v. Arizona... applies retroactively to cases already final on direct review.' 4 However, this apparent simplicity conceals the fact that 124 S. Ct. 2519 (2004).
Author: Marc Johnson
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W77723865
