Work

Commentary on M.D.S. Braine, “Children's first word combinations”

Year: 1976
Type: editorial
Abstract: A descriptive analysis is presented of the syntactic patterns in 16 corpora of word combinations from 11 children learning either English (six children), Samoan, Finnish, Hebrew, or Swedish.The mean utterance lengths range up to about 1.7 morphemes.There are both reanalyses of corpora in the literature and new corpora.The data indicate that each child has learned a number of positional formulae that map components of meaning into positions in the surface structure.Each formula expresses a specific, often quite narrow, range of relational conceptual content.In each corpus, the bulk of the combinations are generated by a small number of such formulae; the differences between one corpus and another are considerable, and their nature indicates that the formulae are independent acquisitions.The formulae are not broad rules of the kind usual in transformational grammars; and the semantic categories are usually much more specific than those of case grammars or those proposed by Schlesinger (although Schlesinger's views are supported in other respects).Also, there is no evidence for grammatical word classes.In general, the evidence indicates less grammatical competence at this stage of development than children are being credited with in much current work.Two kinds of phenomena involving free word order are noted.One kind, not previously reported, is called a "groping pattern": positional formulae are sometimes preceded by an earlier stage in which the components are unordered.The lack of order is due to the child groping to express a meaning before he has learned a rule that determines the position of the elements.The other kind is due to the learning of two formulae, one for each order: longitudinal study of some cases indicates that the two orders were learned at separate times and that they may have subtly different semantic content.MONOGRAPHS When put together, the corpora have, I believe, a clear and rather straightforward story to tell about the nature and basis of children's first syntactic structures.This is that the first productive structures are formulae of limited scope for realizing specific kinds of meanings.They define how a meaning is to be expressed by specifying where in the utterance the words expressing the components of meaning should be placed.That is, the formulae are realization rules that map semantic elements into particular positions in the surface structure.The formulae are limited in scope, in the sense that they are not broad rules of phrase or sentence composition, like the rules S -> NP + VP or VP --V + NP that are typical of current grammars written for both adults and children; their range of content tends to be much narrower than this and is semantically (i.e., conceptually) defined.Each formula is concerned with a specific and often rather narrow kind of semantic content.The data indicate that there are about a score or more of such simple positional formulae that are common in early corpora of text materials from children.The main part of early syntactic development consists in learning one such formula after another.Different children acquire formulae in a different order, and thus there are often differences between one child and another early in development, due to each child having acquired a different sample from this common core of formulae.If these conclusions are valid, it must follow that none of the three theoretical positions summarized above is correct, although Schlesinger's is most nearly adequate.All would err in the same direction: they attribute to the children categories and rules that are substantially more abstract and broader in scope than the data indicate the children possess.That is, at the outset of syntactic development children's syntactic competence is more limited and much more concretely based than current theories suppose.
Institution: New York University
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W780803610
Cites: 20
Cited by: 14
Related to: 10