The pros and cons of selflessness : a hermeneutic critique of silencing the self theory
Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: Silencing the self theory (Jack, 1 987,, 1 991, 1 999) traces gender differences in depression to many women's moral orientation toward the interests of others ahead of one's own needs.In this thesis, it is argued that the theory subsequently denigrates selflessness in all its forms, a stance that reflects Jack's own moral individualism.Through a detailed hermeneutic analysis of silencing the self theory (STST), the author argues that the theory a) conceptualizes a self that is consistent with individualistic ontology, b) takes for granted the universally problematic nature of selflessness because it conflicts with individualism, c) fails to consider the potentially beneficial aspects of selflessness, even as they are revealed by Jack or the participants in Jack's research, and d) possibly contributes to the inequality and injustice experienced by women relative to men.Implications for future research and practice are provided. Silencing the Self Theory iv DedicationTo my loving wife Jenny, who miracylously tolerated me through the ups and downs of writing this thesis.Truly, her love and selflessness has been a priceless gift to me.
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Benjamin Cue
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Reduced inequalities
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W79593574
