Policing in the iron cage : the tensions between the bureaucratic mandate and street level reality
Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In April 2002 a National Crime Recording Standard (NCRS) was introduced across police forces in England and Wales.The intention of this standard, resultant of two highly critical reports regarding police recording of crime, was to improve crime data and promote a victim focussed approach.Research in the field of crime recording emphasises police reporting and recording mechanisms, with a significant reliance placed on police data.However, inter-personal and situational factors determining the ways in which notification of an event is, or is not, translated into a crime record are often inadequately explored.Consequently, there is little recent knowledge regarding the views of individuals reporting an event and the way in which they, through the interactions with the police, affect recording rates.This thesis explores these effects and investigates the impact of deviation from the rules governing crime recording upon service user experiences and satisfaction.Incident logs from three forces were analysed, officer focus groups and questionnaire-based surveys were undertaken and interviews were conducted with service users.Perceptions of service users and police officers vis-à-vis the effectiveness of police intervention were examined, together with the efficacy of previous research methodologies employed to gauge recording rates, the rules regarding crime recording and the existent performance In particular I would like to express my gratitude to Tony Donnelly and Andy Gilks both of whom had the unenviable task of reviewing the draft.Their comments on both the format and content proved invaluable.My thanks also extend to Paul Coombes who, despite being under unremitting pressure to deliver on the work front, managed to ensure I was given time to complete the thesis.I would also like to thank those three forces that facilitated my research and especially the officers and staff who allowed me to intrude into their 'real' worlds.I never imagined when I started out in the world of academia that I would have reached this point and the credit for much of my academic evolution, and indeed at times revolution rests with my supervisors Alan Marlow and John Pitts; to both, I shall be forever indebted.Finally a huge thank you to my wonderful wife Tracy whose patience, understanding and encouragement kept me going when completion seemed so far off.
Author: Stephen A. Hallam
Institution: University of Bedfordshire
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W83537706
