Work

Theoretical and methodological exploration of portrayals of Native Americans in children's fiction

Year: 1983
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This is an exploratory study into the theoretical and methodo logical issues concerning portrayals of Native Americans in children's fiction.The purpose of this study is to analyze the portrayals of Native Americans with the goal of determining whether such portrayals in children's fiction are descriptive or evaluative.This study develops a theoretical foundation for the analysis of portrayals of Native Americans in children's fiction and selectively applies known techniques and methods to measure such portrayals.Through this process methodological issues concerning content analysis are evaluated and their data findings compared.Both quantitative and qualitative methods are used to measure and analyze the portrayals of Native Americans and Non-Native Americans in children's fiction.Quantitatively, Pratt's (1971; 1972) Evaluative Coefficient Analysis method is used to measure the use of evaluative words to portray subjects in such books.Semi-quantitatively, Garcia's (1978; 1979) thematic analysis is used to measure the presence and frequency of themes within the portrayal of Native Americans.Qualitatively, the categories of story plot, character and group portrayals, and impressions and impressionistic techniques are employed to measure the portrayals of Native Americans and Non-Native Americans.The sample, composed from a ten percent random sample from a previously identified population, consists of six books published between 1968 and 1982.This study concludes that portrayals of Native Americans in children's fiction tend to be more evaluative, negative, and judgmental than for Non-Native Americans.It is concluded that through stylistic methods, reinforced by perpetuated themes, portrayals of Native Americans remain static over time.More importantly, however, is the conclusion that the portrayals of Native Americans now are more subtle, more latent, and harder to manifestly perceive.Such conclusions imply the need for increased theoretical and methodological studies, as well additional in-depth analyses of recent books portraying Native Americans.To my loving wife, Cindy, and to our beautiful son, Kristoffer, this thesis is dedicated.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W848267121
Cites: 272
Cited by:
Related to: 10