Work

Meta-Analysis of Entrance Standards for Undergraduate Nursing and Selected Allied Health Programs

Year: 2010
Type: review
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of admission standards that have been used for undergraduate allied health and nursing programs.Five professions met the initial criteria including the awarding of a 2-or 4-year degree, a national board examination administered upon program completion, and published research covering entrance standards.The professions are: dental hygiene, medical technology, registered nursing, radiologic technology, and respiratory therapy.Random-format meta-analysis was used to evaluate 28 years of research gathered from both published and unpublished documents.Length of time used for data collection was defined by published research using outcome parameters, including national board examinations.Forty-eight studies resulted in 230 comparable effect size variables.Twenty-one predictors were identified in the research and were measured against 4 criterion variables.ACT English, entrance grade point average, and biology were statistically significant predictors for all 5 professions.While no predictors had a shared variance across all professions, 8 predictors resulted in shared variance when moderators were considered.These included: ACT English, math, science, and social science; chemistry; entrance grade point average; SAT verbal; and a specialized test, the AHPAT.Each of these measures used board scores as the criterion measure.Moderators included the length of time used to gather data, year of study or publication, whether the study was published, and the profession.Profession had the largest effect on the statistical significance of the predictors.Two-and 4-year programs were identified as subgroups.Considering the moderator, profession, only 2 predictors were affected by the subgroups: entrance grade point average in Medical Technology and ACT science in Registered Nursing.When I entered the doctorate program, my interview team asked what I would like to get from the college.I asked for guidance, mentoring, and facilitation.I believe Kent State has given me what I asked for and more.My dissertation team epitomized these qualities and allowed me to pursue a newer statistical technique, providing me with support through the process.I would like to thank the following individuals for their assistance in this project.Dr. Mark Kretovics has served as my advisor and committee chair in his formal capacity but more than that he has served as a resource.He exemplifies the best of adult mentoring as he has been supportive allowing me to pursue my own topic with an uncommon statistical technique, going so far as to educate himself on the methodology and converse with me as I worked through the process.To me, this was invaluable and represents the best of what an advisor should be.Dr. Susan Iverson practices the best educational methods as she kept me involved with campus life throughout the dissertation process.I have a career and family life off campus, so the requests to work with her were met with willingness and gratitude.I enjoyed every minute of it.Dr. Alicia Crowe agreed to serve as graduate faculty representative during the summer months.Her attention to detail in the dissertation was first-rate.I appreciated her comments and suggestions and couldn't have asked for a better resource.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W88719705
FWCI: 0.154
Cites: 107
Cited by: 4
Related to: 10