Decision making in uncertain environments: a resting state EEG study
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Prior studies have shown that punishment and reward sensitivity influences decision making in a gambling task with a stable and predictable environment. Some unpublished data suggest that this also holds true in unpredictable situations in which the application of reversal learning is needed to optimally perform in a gambling task. The behavioral inhibition system (BIS) regulates and processes punishment, while the behavioral activation system (BAS) does this for rewarding stimuli. It is claimed that the neurobiological substrates of the BIS and BAS can be found in the prefrontal cortex, more specifically in the alpha band of an EEG signal (8-12 Hz). A right-sided asymmetry in the PFC indicates a higher sensitivity to punishment, while left-sided asymmetry indicates a higher sensitivity to reward. This research will try to further investigate the effects on the BIS and BAS as determined by EEG recordings on decision making in a gambling task where reversal learning is needed. The main hypothesis of the present study is that the amount of reversal learning in an uncertain environment can be predicted by measurements of an asymmetry found in the alpha band (8-12 Hz) in baseline EEG. It was expected that a right-sided asymmetry would correlate positively with reversal learning while a left-sided asymmetry would correlate negatively with reversal learning. A novel task was used that consisted of changing reward-punishment contingencies to induce reversal learning. Reversal learning was measured by determining a behavioral adaptation index calculated from task performance. Self-reported BIS and BAS data was obtained through a questionnaire. Resting state EEG data was recorded and a frontal asymmetry index was subtracted from this data. The main hypothesis was not supported by the present research; Results showed that EEG asymmetries calculated from the alpha band (8-12) from baseline EEG recordings did not predict reversal learning. Furthermore, self-reported BIS and BAS scores did not correlate with frontal asymmetry, failing to support the notion that such an asymmetry reflects differences in punishment sensitivity. Finally, self-reported BIS and BAS scores did not correlate significantly with reversal learning, indicating that under uncertain circumstances punishment sensitivity does not affect task performance. Conclusively, none of the hypothesis were confirmed by this study. However, one effect was found that could indicate that reversal learning might be affected by situational factors. The selfreported BIS scores correlated negatively with reversal learning in a certain part of the task. This indicates that self-reported BIS scores can predict reversal learning, but only under certain circumstances such as previous and starting situation. Still, this finding was not sufficient to support the hypothesis in the present study. More research is advised to gain insight in the effect of situational factors on reversal learning as determined by either frontal asymmetry or self-reported BIS and BAS scores.
Author: J.I. Cijsouw
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W908616659
